Quick answer: Use two public tools, not one. Medicare Care Compare gives every Medicare-certified nursing home 1-to-5 star ratings for inspections, staffing, quality measures and an overall score. U.S. News rates short-term rehabilitation and long-term care separately and, in its 2027 list released November 10, 2026, rated 14 of 45 Buffalo-area homes high performing, according to Skilled Nursing News. Neither list replaces a visit, a look at recent inspection reports, or a check of New York's nursing home profiles.

What changed on November 10, 2026?
U.S. News & World Report published its 2027 Best Nursing Homes ratings, evaluating more than 14,600 skilled nursing facilities in all 50 states and Washington, D.C., on 17 quality measures. 18% earned a "Best Nursing Home" designation in short-term rehabilitation, long-term care or both. Rehab and long-term care are scored separately because they serve different patients.
U.S. News said top-rated homes averaged 19% more total staffing per resident per day, twice as much physical therapy, 19% fewer emergency room visits for short-term rehab patients, and 21% fewer hospital readmissions among long-term residents than other facilities. Skilled Nursing News, citing the U.S. News researcher, also reported that depressive symptoms among long-term residents rose from 10% to 13% compared with the prior year, and that 14 of 45 nursing homes in the Buffalo metropolitan area were rated high performing in one category or both. About 43 metro areas had 10 or more high-performing homes.
Read our same-day news brief, U.S. News releases 2027 nursing home ratings; Buffalo metro has 14 high performers, and the Senior Sentinel story. Then use the how-to steps below before a discharge planner asks you to pick a facility.
How do Medicare's star ratings work?
CMS created the Five-Star Quality Rating System so families can compare nursing homes more easily and know which questions to ask. On Medicare Care Compare, choose "Nursing homes including rehab services," enter a ZIP code or facility name, and open a home's profile. You can compare up to three homes side by side.
Each home gets an overall rating of 1 to 5 stars, plus separate ratings for health inspections, staffing and quality measures. Five stars means much above average; one star means much below average. CMS builds the overall rating starting from the health inspection rating, then adjusting for staffing and quality-measure results. Inspection ratings draw on recent annual surveys, complaint investigations and infection-control surveys. Staffing ratings use payroll-based nurse hours and turnover. Quality-measure ratings use a mix of long-stay and short-stay measures.
CMS cautions that no rating system covers everything that matters for a particular person, such as specialized dementia or rehab care, or how easy it is for family to visit. Medicare's guide to choosing a nursing home (PDF) says star ratings are not a substitute for visiting. Also look at whether a home has been cited for abuse, and read the inspection reports on the same profile.
How should you use the U.S. News list?
Match the rating to the stay you need. After a hip replacement or a stroke, the short-term rehabilitation rating matters more than the long-term care score. For a permanent bed, look at the long-term care results, staffing, and how the home handles mood and depression, especially given the rise in depressive symptoms U.S. News flagged for long-term residents.
The official metro list is on the U.S. News Buffalo, NY nursing homes page. A high-performing designation is one data point, not a guarantee and not a recommendation of a specific facility by Cardinal. Homes that are not on the "best" list can still be the right fit if they are closer, have an open bed, or offer a service you need. Confirm any listing against Care Compare and a visit.
What else should a Western New York family check?
New York publishes facility profiles at profiles.health.ny.gov/nursing_home. If a resident needs an advocate, the state's Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program is at ltcombudsman.ny.gov. For hospital-to-rehab timing, see our hospital discharge guide and nursing homes in Buffalo. Town pages are also available for nearby communities in Erie and Niagara counties.
If a parent may instead stay home with support, start with Homeward by Cardinal or our comparison of staying home versus assisted living. Homeward begins with a free 15-minute triage call, then a $695 Home Readiness Assessment: one in-home visit with a score out of 100, a ranked fix list and a recommended plan. A Discharge Rush assessment within 48 hours of a hospital or rehab discharge is $895, and a reassessment is $295. Monthly plans are Essentials at $495, Guided at $995 (recommended) and Full Support at $2,495, with extra hours at $175/hour. See Homeward plans and pricing or call (716) 300-2769.
A simple checklist for this week
- Look up each facility you are considering on Care Compare and on the U.S. News Buffalo list, and write down whether the rating is for short-term rehab, long-term care, or both.
- Open the inspection report and staffing section, not only the overall stars.
- Check the New York nursing home profile for the same facility.
- Visit at a mealtime or shift change, and ask how the home screens for depression and what activities it offers.
- Ask the hospital discharge planner which homes have an open bed that matches the type of stay you need, then compare those options rather than picking the first available bed.
Common questions
What is the difference between U.S. News ratings and Medicare star ratings?
Medicare Care Compare gives every Medicare-certified nursing home an overall 1-to-5 star rating, plus separate stars for health inspections, staffing and quality measures. U.S. News rates short-term rehabilitation and long-term care separately and names a smaller group of homes as high performing. Use both, then visit.
How many Buffalo-area nursing homes were high performing in the 2027 U.S. News ratings?
Skilled Nursing News, citing the 2027 U.S. News ratings released November 10, 2026, reported that 14 of 45 nursing homes in the Buffalo metropolitan area were rated high performing in short-term rehabilitation, long-term care or both. About 43 metro areas had 10 or more high-performing homes.
Can I choose a nursing home from the ratings alone?
No. CMS says no rating system covers everything that matters, including specialized care or how easy it is for family to visit. Medicare's guide also says star ratings are not a substitute for an in-person visit. Check recent inspection reports and go at a mealtime or shift change.
Where should a Buffalo family look up a specific nursing home?
Use Medicare Care Compare (choose Nursing homes including rehab services), the U.S. News Buffalo-area list, and New York's nursing home profiles at profiles.health.ny.gov. Cardinal's nursing homes in Buffalo page and hospital discharge guide can help you organize the next step. Cardinal charges one simple rate, $195 an hour, for all services.
Sources: U.S. News 2027 Best Nursing Homes (PR Newswire, Nov 10, 2026); Skilled Nursing News report on the 2027 ratings; U.S. News: Best Nursing Homes in Buffalo, NY; CMS Five-Star Quality Rating System; Medicare Care Compare; Medicare: Your Guide to Choosing a Nursing Home (PDF); New York State nursing home profiles; New York Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program. Accessed Nov 10, 2026. Cardinal is not affiliated with U.S. News, CMS or the facilities those sites list; names identify them only.
Talk with a local Cardinal advisor · Hospital discharge help · Nursing homes in Buffalo
More reading: Senior Care News: 2027 U.S. News ratings · Senior Sentinel story · Senior care options in Buffalo, compared
Talk with a local advisor
Tell us a little about what is happening. A Cardinal advisor will call you back. We serve Erie and Niagara counties.
